Excuse me if I don’t limit the “Lives
Matter” slogan to just black people. It
should also apply to Indigenous peoples in Canada as well as other marginalized
peoples. 2020 could be remembered as the
Lives Matter year. In most of Canada
outside a few big cities, racism applies to Indigenous peoples more than to
black people. Of course there is racism
in Canada.
I cannot understand racism in any
form. Probably because I was not brought
up that way. My father and mother had
respect for everyone. So, it is hard for
me to see any reason why anyone would resent, fear or hate anyone of another
colour or ethnic group. It constantly
baffles me that we can extol black and indigenous athletes and movie stars and
yet be prejudice against common people of similar races. You can condemn an individual for what they
did or are doing, but you cannot condemn an individual for what they are.
Many years ago, I was a young naval officer
on exchange with the US Navy. It was the
early 1970s, not long after the civil rights movement. We were stationed in Newport, Rhode Island in
supposedly liberal New England. A few
months after I got there, our command was told that the following summer we
were being moved to Charleston, South Carolina, the heart of the old
south. We had a black Petty Officer on
the staff who was originally from Brooklyn, New York. I asked him one day what he thought of the
move south. His answer was quite
insightful I thought. He said, “At least
down there I know what to expect.” He was
pointing out that in the so-called liberal north, the racism was more subtle
but still present, whereas in the south the prejudice was overt and
expected. In Canada, we are much more
like liberal New England where most of the prejudice is more subtle and unknown
where and when it will take place.
People talk of systemic racism – that the
racism is built into the “system”, whatever the system may be. But that is a cop-out. It takes away the individual responsibility that
is really at the heart of racism. It is
individuals who make the decision to hate, abuse and even kill minority people. You will not find any written directive in
any reputable company, government or organization in Canada that advocates
racism. It is individuals who carry out
or support any form of it. It is
individuals who must take responsibility for any “systemic” racism: the HR manager
who will no accept any resume from a black or indigenous person; the senior
manager who refuses to promote a Muslim; or the foreman who gives all the bad
jobs to Jews hoping that they will fail.
It is individuals who make decisions, guide policy and set rules, not
some impersonal “system”. No law or
government edict will ever stamp out racism.
This is the point that so many opinion
writers will stop as if to say, “There, that is the problem. Now someone else must fix it.” But I’m going to venture on and try to offer
some remedies.